Spearhead Research Logo

NEWSLETTER
MAY - AUGUST 2009

From the Director
  • Spearhead followed the major regional developments and our analysts and researchers worked frantically to stay ahead of the rapidly changing situations.
  • By far the most significant event was the failure of the peace accord in Swat between the Pakistan government and the Tehrik Nifaz e Sharia. This happened after the cleric leading the movement in Swat refused to lay down weapons and criticized Pakistan’s constitution and Islamic values. The Taliban supporting him threatened to dominate the entire country and pushed out of Swat into other areas while increasing violence. Videos of Taliban atrocities on women and unarmed civilians and their acts of terror turned political and media opinion against them. The military operation that followed has been successful and has full public, political and media support. Swat has been secured and more remarkably the military has ensured the return of the large numbers of people who were displaced.
  • Subsequent military operations have secured the northern and southern flanks of FATA and established a stronghold on South Waziristan where the major Taliban leader was killed in a US Drone strike. The TTP has a new leader and is trying to assert itself again by random acts of violence.
  • The bilateral situation with India remains mostly unchanged with dialogue stalled and India insisting that it can be resumed only after the Mumbai issue has been resolved. A meeting between the Prime Ministers did raise hopes but domestic pressures in India hampered any progress. The next possible contact could be on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly Meeting in New York.
  • Spearhead followed the Iranian election and its aftermath and continues to monitor the Iran-US relationship. The violence in China’s Xinjiang province was a significant event for Pakistan and Spearhead analyzed the situation continuously. The focus remains on US-Russian interaction and Russia-China peace exercises under the SCO format against the common threat of terrorism.
  • The most important event was the Afghan Presidential election amid escalating violence and mounting US/NATO casualties. Spearhead analysis indicated that a war torn country riddled with corruption and violence would not be changed in any way regardless of the election result. Karzai is likely to be reelected but his new team may not be what the US wanted.
  • Spearhead also monitored the internal situation with special attention to the political developments, levels of violence, the counter insurgency campaign in FATA and the situation in Baluchistan. The political and economic situations registered marginal improvement with the government announcing a textile policy and a major political change by renaming the northern areas Gilgit-Baltistan with provincial status.
  • The US-Pakistan and UK-Pakistan relationships continued on a steady track with a stream of visitors from both countries. The US Kerry-Luger Legislation will bring in almost 1.5 billion dollars in aid while the UK Prime Minister promised almost 650 million to Pakistan during President Zardari’s visit to UK. The ‘Friends of Pakistan’ met in Istanbul Turkey and are due to meet again in New York in September.

 

The Spearhead team is well knit and doing well. Irsa Hussain joined us in June and is well settled. She brings a wealth of experience and expertise to Spearhead. We also shifted to a bigger office on the second floor in the same building and quickly got fully operational.

 

Spearhead Research hopes to continue its activity at the same pace and with the same intensity in the coming months. There are many interesting situations evolving in Afghanistan, Iran and India. The internal situation is also likely to improve by the end of the year. There are ICNND meetings in Cairo, Delhi and Pakistan. Global Zero meeting will be held in Moscow and the IISS Manama Dialogue in Bahrein.

 

We at Spearhead Research are committed to promoting a culture of research and analysis. We will bring you insightful analyses, selected articles and issue oriented research as well as opinion pieces and points of view on our vibrant moderated forum.

 

Latest Analyses by Spearhead Research
Swat

The Battle for Swat
The operation by the security forces started against Buner and Lower Dir to disperse the Taliban, open up logistic routes and tighten the noose against Swat. In Buner the strongholds in Sultanwas and Pir Baba have been destroyed. In Lower Dir a training camp has been eliminated with the thrust in the eastern valley route to Swat. This linkage between Bajaur and Swat could be used by the Taliban for reinforcements from Southern Afghanistan from where most aliens come unchecked into FATA...

Nuke_fuss

Why all this fuss about Pakistan’s Nuclear Assets?
This shift in perceptions and policy is important---it should have happened much earlier but the Taliban intentions had to be exposed first. The military now has the initiative and the response by the insurgents is through attacks in urban areas to weaken the resolve to sustain the fight against them. The recent assassination of a deeply respected religious scholar could lead to a more strident religious opinion against the Taliban and their brand of Islam...

War of Necessity
Wars of Necessity and Wars of Choice
Wars are matters of judgment, good or bad. Necessity perhaps and choice surely are superficial distinctions. A war of necessity implies responding to and being justified by a first attack. A war of choice is taken in this context to mean a pre-emptive war or war of aggression with manufactured or indeed without casus belli. Such distinctions are misleading...
Divergences

DIVERGENCES
Pakistan understands that the insurgency in its FATA area springs from Southern Afghanistan and is supported by the Taliban/Al Qaeda there---it is therefore unlikely that Pakistan would be so moronic as to fight the Afghan supported insurgents in one sector and support people behind them in another sector. It does make sense however, that Pakistan would keep all options open to bring the insurgency to an end---something that can happen only with an end to the violence in Afghanistan...

Recycled Karzai

The Recycled Karzai
It is the recycled Karzai that will demand attention. He has been moving away from puppet status by asking for investigations into the collateral damage from US air strikes especially the one in which a large number of innocent Pashtuns including women and children were killed. He has also talked of a time line for US troop withdrawal from Afghanistan. More recently he has inducted four notorious warlords into his fold and they will inevitably be accommodated in powerful positions if Karzai wins. These people have long track records and even longer memories and they know how to acquire and wield power. Karzai has sent out discreet signal of possible dialogue with the Taliban and he has moved to mend fences with Pakistan...

Terror_trial

THE TERROR TRAIL
Last night a bombing attack destroyed the Pearl Continental Hotel—located in a high security zone and Peshawer’s only five star hotel. Before that the ISI ‘s provincial headquarters in Lahore had been bombed and in between there was the suicide bombing of the Police Rescue 15 building in Islamabad and a bloody attack on a mosque in Dir. On the streets of Karachi political infighting between two factions of a political party led to over 40 killings in drive-by shooting incidents. There were media reports of targeted killings in Baluchistan. A political confrontation between the major parties seems to be raising its head...

 

Present_Future_Concern

Present and Future Concerns
With no real shortage of food in the country Pakistanis are aghast at TV images of people clamoring for staples like flour and sugar---the result of price gouging and the manipulation of supply and demand. Existing tax payers and businesses are being harassed instead of being encouraged and new ones created. Those actually helping and supporting us are being vilified without considering the facts. Effective governance would make the government response proactive rather than reactive and target those who are undermining it...

Khanjar

Tora Bora-Anaconda and Now Khanjar
Dubbed Operation Khanjar or ‘Strike of the Sword’ the US military offensive in Afghanistan’s Helmand province has been underway for almost a week. Helmand in Southern Afghanistan was a Taliban stronghold and the largest opium producing area in the world. The Pentagon has described it as the largest and fastest part of the new US strategy involving 1000 of the 21000 newly inducted US troops and 650 Afghan forces. The stated aim of the operation is to clear insurgents from there ahead of the August 20 presidential election...

Big_Wishes
THREE VERY BIG WISHES
Back from “resetting” relations with Russia and then conferring with the G-8 plus before stopping over in Ghana, President Barak Obama continues a full court press on resolving concurrently the myriad of crises, dangers and issues facing the nation. If the veritable fairy godmother could grant Obama three wishes to help him, choosing them could prove to be the most daunting of the president’s problems...
Big_Thraw

The Big Thaw
Much is being read in the meeting between the Prime Ministers of India and Pakistan in Sharam al Shaikh. India has been at pains to downplay its significance saying that the institutionalized dialogue can only be resumed after Pakistan has acted to prosecute the people behind the terror attacks in Mumbai. India had called off the dialogue in the wake of those attacks. Pakistan has repeatedly suggested dialogue...

Kilju_Jolt

 

THE KILJU JOLT
The North Korean test is a reality. It could be a bargaining ploy but it is probably driven by its insecurity just as security concerns forced Pakistan to test after India tested. It is time to consider the impact of the security environment as a driver for proliferation and seriously debate how that environment can be changed to prevent proliferation. President Obama has made a strong push for disarmament and non-proliferation. There are calls or him to take a bold initiative to go for direct talks with the North Korea and Iran besides reviewing the whole strategic environment...

Latest article available for download:

PDF File Amnesty International Report 2009: The State of the World’s Human Rights

PDF File India in 2009 - The First Quarter

PDF File Swat deal and implication for the rest of Pakistan

PDF File Is the War in Afghanistan in the Interests of the United States and its Allies?

Pakistan: Second Quarter of Year 2009
Regional and International Landscape of Second Quarter 2009

In the second quarter of year 2009 we see the vortex of War on Terror shifting from Afghanistan to the polemical Af-Pak region. After signing a Peace Deal with Tehrik-e-Nifaz-e-Shariat-e-Mohammadi (TNSM), Pakistan witnessed a brief respite from country-wide acts of terrorism. However, tides turned upon TNSM’s refusal to disarm. Becoming exceedingly unpopular on account of its draconian and regressive punishments against women TNSM led Shariah Nizam quickly began to relapse. Sporadic assaults on law enforcement agencies and suicide bombings in public places resumed.

To mark the climax, late in April Taliban of Swat seized Buner District of NWFP. (Buner, lying at a tangential distance of 60 miles from Islamabad was part of Malakand Division until year 2000 and comprises a mountain valley loosely binding a number of villages that are given seven sub-divisions.) The incident came in consonance with TNSM’s explicit intention to ‘spread out’ of Malakand Division declaring the Constitution of Pakistan un-Islamic. The Taliban left Buner in a few days yet their stay however short-lived, left security monitors across the world panic-stricken. At this point US based analysts began voicing overwrought probabilities that put the safety of Pakistan’s Nuclear Assets into question. Soon Pakistan was to respond with resounding hand, proving all such observations unwarranted. Conversely, the final weeks of April proved episodic and compelled the government of Pakistan to launch a military operation in Swat.

Pakistan’s decision to launch Operation Rah-e-Rast against extremist miscreants of Swat exercised complete confidence of the people of Pakistan. In the course of the operation massive displacement of Swatis took place; yet, since the operation was swift, decisive and successful, by July resettlement of the internally displaced Swatis began to take effect. As of now more than ninety per cent of the internally displaced have been resettled.

Pakistan anticipates international support for the massive collateral damage incurred during the operation that inflicted a heavy blow on Swatis. This quarter, Pakistan became the theatre of War on Terror, in addition to being an ally and active Combatant engaged in an ongoing military campaign against the miscreants and terrorists linked to international terrorist outfits operating within Pakistan.

The drive against terrorist and extremist elements does not discount territorial sovereignty of Pakistan and Afghanistan by virtue of Durand Line. On the other hand in order to further cooperative efforts in rooting out terrorists from both sides of the Durand Line, Pakistan shares comprehensive intelligence and surveillance information with US, ISAF and NATO forces required for carrying out coordinated attacks against terrorists. It is widely believed that US Drone attacks inside Pakistan’s territory may not be conducted without prior knowledge or some sort of nod from Pakistan. In the first week of August Baitullah Mehsud was reported to have been killed as a result of US Drone.

After subsequent weeks of speculation and reports of infighting, the Taleban appointed a top militant commander to replace Baitullah as their new chief. The appointment of Hakimullah Mehsud, a 28-year-old commander known for his aggressiveness and believed to have masterminded the attack on Sri Lankan cricket team early this year hints on a new wave of militant violence in the urban cities of Pakistan.

In July 2009 US introduced more boots on the ground to launch Operation Khanjar (strike of the sword) in Helmand province, South of Afghanistan. This was the first major allied offensive in Afghanistan since Obama’s new war policy. At this time Pakistan Army was undertaking counterinsurgency in South Waziristan where Baitullah was to be targeted later in August. As opposed to the performance of Pakistan Army, Operation Khanjar has not met with comparable success. For the UK forces July 2009 has been the deadliest month in entire Afghan War. The Presidential elections held in August 2009 in Afghanistan, too, were marked with violence and unrest.

This quarter as events compelled Pakistan to assert against terrorists, Pakistan sought to completely wipe out the extremist in order to bring the previously ungoverned swathes of Northern Areas into the fold of governance. Thus, after the success of Operation Rah-e-Rast, the government of Pakistan on August 29, 2009 announced Northern Areas as a province and named it “Gilgit-Baltistan”. Gilgit-Balistan would enjoy provincial status complete with its own elected Assembly and provincial autonomy and a Governor.

Pakistan’s bilateral situation with India waltzed around Prime Minister Manmohan Singh snubbing President Zardari in Russia while beaming at Prime Minister Gilani at Sharm-el-Sheikh - a smile that faded soon after he landed India. With dialogue process taking one step forward and two steps backward and India insisting on Mumbai issue as a prerequisite to resumption of talks despite the Joint Statement signed at Sharm-el-Sheikh, the composite dialogue continues to simmer in the backburner. India’s involvement in Baluchistan Insurgency versus Mumbai façade, have yet to assume exact bearings in the Indo-Pak calculus for the Composite Dialogue to move forward. As Domestic pressures in India graduate the pace of Composite Dialogue critical issues relating Energy and Environment that require regional consensus await a healthy ambience between India and its neighborhood. Pakistan’s next possible contact with India could be on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly Meeting in New York.

On the regional landscape, India and Iran held elections in the month of June and August respectively.  While India gracefully recovered a Congress led coalition, Iran witnessed country-wide unrest on Ahmedenejad’s re-election. In the recently held Afghan elections similar strife was witnessed and further unrest is foreseen as a result of three likely outcomes: a run-off between Karzai and Abdullah, boycott by either of the two main candidates or even Karzai’s re-election.

Late in June China witnessed ethnic unrest in the Xinjiang Province between Uighar Muslim and Han Chinese that spread across the city quickly where three quarters of the population is Han Chinese. Government responded by sending 20,000 security officials to stabilize the situation.  Trials over Xinjiang riots are underway and with 200 people being prosecuted to match the number of casualties. Although the state-owned newspaper did not give a breakdown of Uighurs vs. Han going on trial but it is said that more than 170 Uighurs and 20 Han lawyers have been assigned to the suspects.

In May North Korea carried out its second ever Nuclear Test, drawing protests from US, China and Russia. Carrying out another nuke test through May, North Korea persisted that it no longer considered itself bound by the terms of 1953 truce that led to a seize fire between the two Koreas. Yet in June it proposed reopening talks with the South over Kaesong Factory that is run by the Southern companies and employs workers from the North. In response to the nuclear tests UN Security Council voted unanimously for the imposition of tougher sanctions on North Korea. Pyongyang responded to it by saying that it takes this decision as a US-led blockade against itself and therefore an “act of war” that might compel it to “weaponise” its plutonium stocks. However beginning August, after former US President Bill Clinton visited North Korea to help release US journalists, Pyongyang made series of conciliatory gestures toward Seoul: first by sending a delegation to the funeral of former South Korean President Kim Dae-Jung, then freeing four South Korean fisherman who had been detained for a month and finally agreeing to resume programme of family reunions suspended since early 2008.

In Iran, recovering from chaotic elections, Ahmedinejad went breathless in defense against  the expected sanctions upon  Tehran’s Nuclear Program while Israeli President Shimon Peres successfully lobbied across Europe for the same. We anticipate the fate of Tehran’s Nuclear Program during the IAEA Conference scheduled to take place in September 2009.

In June, during his speech to the Muslim World in Cairo University, Obama demanded immediate halting of Israeli settlements. Israel responded by agreeing to make some minor gestures while ignoring the core issues. In the beginning of this quarter Obama administration appeared to be ready to make a major issue out of this, but later as it surfaced US continues to side Israel’s policies in the Middle East vis-a-vis Iran and Lebanon. Hence fundamental strategic interests have not been compromised for the issue of settlements under Obama administration.

After the Russo-Georgian war last August Obama administration aimed to ‘resetting’ US-Russian relations. Despite Obama’s pleasant trip to Moscow his efforts have only yielded a ‘qualified success’ at decelerating strategic and diplomatic contest between the two in Central Asia and Eastern Europe. On the whole, U.S-Russian relations generally remain antagonistic this year.

 

Conclusion
The War on Terror in Afghanistan and the linked Taliban insurgency in Afghanistan remains the most important evolving situation for Pakistan. The simmering discontent and sporadic violence is also connected to this situation. We will monitor and analyze this scenario.

The strategic relationship with the US and the bilateral relationship with India are two important relationships for Pakistan. We hope to not only monitor these but will encourage positive developments.

We hope to introduce issue briefs covering topical events. These will be available in electronic and print format. We may precede these with sponsored discussions.

We do face a financial challenge and will continue to welcome and solicit funded projects or requests for analysis and research on specific subjects. We also welcome your comments, views and opinions.


Spearhead Research - Contact Information

Our new office address is:

Office No. 17, Second Floor
Park Lane Towers,
172 Tufail Road,

Cantonment 54800
Lahore - Pakistan

Telephones:
+92 342 6622335
+92 342 6622336

Fax:
+92 342 6622337

Email:
info@spearheadresearch.org

Visitors at Spearhead Research
Visits by Spearhead Research

Spearhead welcomed the following visitors:

  • Mr Lawrnce Korb and his team interacted with Spearhead on the current situation.

  • Mr Vali-Nasr, Adviser to Mr Holbrooke met the Director.

  • The Director held discussions with JICA representatives and other researchers from Japan.

  • Mr Paolo Cotta Ramosino from Pugwash and Mr Moeed Yusuf

The Director participated in the following events:

  • ICNND (International Commission on Nuclear Proliferation and Disarmament) in Peking and Moscow.

  • IISS ( international Institute for Strategic Studies) Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore.

  • A Global Zero meeting in Washington DC. He addressed audiences at Brookings, the Middle East Institute and the Atlantic Council in Washington DC

 

Future Directions
Useful Links

Image

Spearhead Research will continue its work regarding issues in the regional and global context.

Our focus will be on development within Pakistan especially the events across our borders, the internal security situation and the economic environment. We solicit funded projects and input.

© 2009 Spearhead Research ®
www.spearheadresearch.org